Papa John's Franchise Closures: What Item 20 Will Show

On November 9, Papa ZHS LLC, a Pennsylvania Papa John's franchisee owned by Yasir Hussain, filed for Chapter 11 along with four affiliated companies. The filing came four days after Papa John's said it had closed 239 restaurants so far in 2026, 146 of them in North America. Papa John's franchise closures are now running on two tracks: a planned pruning of old, low-volume stores, and the unplanned kind. Both will end up in Item 20 of the next franchise disclosure document (FDD), and they mean very different things for a buyer or a lender.

What the Papa ZHS bankruptcy filing confirms

Chapter 11 is the part of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code that lets a business keep operating while it restructures its debts under court supervision. According to reporting by IBTimes, the debtors are Papa ZHS LLC, ZHS Pittsburgh LLC, ZHS Cranberry LLC, ZHS McKeesport LLC and Papa ZHS Cleveland LLC, and the petitions were filed in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania.

The Papa ZHS LLC petition lists assets of $100,000 to $500,000 and liabilities of $1 million to $10 million, including more than $2.9 million in unsecured claims. The largest listed creditors, as reported, are a stack of commercial lenders:

  • Itria Ventures LLC, about $909,000 across three loans
  • The Small Business Administration, more than $811,000 across two loans
  • Bizcap at $275,000 and CFG at $270,000
  • Ascentium Capital, more than $259,000 across three loans, and Balboa Capital, more than $194,000

Hussain's story is the opposite of a tired legacy operator. He started at Papa John's as a dishwasher roughly 20 years ago, opened his first franchise in 2019 and was credited with opening the brand's 6,000th restaurant in February 2025, when he ran 12 locations. A 13th location, in Cleveland, Ohio, appears on the petition. In the coverage we reviewed, Papa John's had not commented on the filing.

The system numbers are company claims from the November 5 third-quarter release and earnings call, outside this week's window and included as background. North American comparable sales fell 8.3% in the quarter, with franchised restaurants down 8.5%. CEO Todd Penegor said the 146 North American closures are nearly half of the 300 the company has committed to through 2027. Management guided to 200 to 250 gross North American closures and 40 to 50 gross openings for 2026.

Why Papa John's franchise closures belong in an Item 20 and Item 19 read

When Papa John's announced the 300-store plan in February, it described the targets as restaurants more than 10 years old, with average unit volume (AUV, annual sales per restaurant) below $600,000 and typically negative four-wall income, meaning the store loses money before corporate overhead. Most are franchisee-owned. That's a defined, intentional cull, and it will show up in Item 20, the FDD section that tracks outlet openings, transfers, terminations, non-renewals, reacquisitions and closures by state.

Run the guidance through simple arithmetic (our math, not the company's): 200 to 250 closures against 40 to 50 openings implies a net North American decline of roughly 150 to 210 restaurants in 2026. A buyer reading Item 20 next year will see a shrinking system. The useful question is whether the shrinkage is concentrated in the stores the company said it would close.

Item 19, the financial performance representation, is where the cull gets subtle. If the lowest-AUV stores leave, the average AUV of the remaining base rises even if no store sells one more pizza. Papa John's has said the same fleet approach lifted U.K. AUVs by 17%. Some of that may be real operating improvement. Some of it is the denominator changing. An Item 19 that improves while Item 20 shrinks needs to be read with both tables open.

The fee stack is moving too. Papa John's plans to cut its technology fee from 1.75% to 1.5% in 2027, set its supply chain margin at 4% for 2027 before stepping to 4.5% in 2028 and 5% in 2029, and raise total marketing to 7% of sales (5% national, 2% local co-op). Those changes belong in Item 6 (other fees) and the required-purchase disclosures in Item 8, and the step-ups matter as much as the 2027 relief.

Five things to check in the next Papa John's FDD

  1. Item 20, Table 3 by state. Look at Pennsylvania and Ohio, and at how exits are classified: terminations, non-renewals, reacquired by franchisor, or ceased operations for other reasons. A planned closure and a failed franchisee can land in different columns.
  2. Item 20 transfers. A spike in transfers alongside closures can mean distressed operators are selling rather than closing. Compare transfer counts to the prior two years.
  3. Item 19 sample size. Check how many restaurants are in the reported group each year. If the count drops and the average rises, separate mix effect from same-store gains.
  4. Item 6 and Item 8 in writing. Confirm the 1.5% tech fee and the 4% supply chain margin appear as disclosed terms, and note when they step back up.
  5. Item 21 and franchisee receivables. Papa John's is public, so read its audited financials for allowances on franchisee receivables or notes. Rising reserves would tell you more about operator stress than any press release.

You can compare these disclosures against other pizza systems in the GetFDD franchise directory. For a recent example of how unit exits read in Item 20, see our breakdown of Golden Corral franchise closures.

What the Papa ZHS bankruptcy doesn't tell us yet

We don't know how many restaurants Papa ZHS and its affiliates were operating on November 9, or whether any will close. Coverage doesn't say whether Hussain built his stores new or bought existing ones, so we can't tell whether any of his units fit the "over 10 years old, under $600,000" profile Papa John's is targeting.

It's also unclear how Papa John's will respond. A franchisor can take units back or steer them to another operator, and each choice shows up differently in Item 20. Last week's Outback franchisee bankruptcy showed one path, with the brand bidding for units itself. Papa John's is moving the other direction, shrinking company ownership toward a mid-single-digit share of North America after refranchising 28 Orlando restaurants in August.

Finally, the Cleveland location. Whether it opened, and on what financing, will matter to any creditor and to anyone tracking Ohio development.

Planned closures are easier to underwrite than leveraged growth

The 300-store plan is ugly on a unit-count chart, but it's disclosed and aimed at stores the company says lose money. A diligence team can model it.

Papa ZHS is the harder case: a fast-growing operator, celebrated by the brand less than two years ago, carrying SBA debt alongside several non-SBA commercial loans. That kind of stress doesn't show up in a franchisor's closure guidance. It shows up in the franchisee's debt stack, and later in Item 20 rows that nobody forecast.

Sources

  • Pizza Marketplace, "Papa Johns franchisee files for Chapter 11," November 12, 2026. Link
  • IBTimes Singapore, "Papa John's Franchisee Files for Bankruptcy as Pizza Chain Closes 239 Restaurants," November 12, 2026. Link
  • Background: Pizza Marketplace, "Papa Johns lowers 2026 outlook, launches Unbox Better transformation strategy," November 5, 2026. Link
  • Background: The Motley Fool, "Papa John's (PZZA) Q3 2026 Earnings Call Transcript," November 5, 2026. Link
  • Background: Restaurant Dive, "Papa Johns will close 300 restaurants," February 26, 2026. Link